Living
Approach, Not Avoidance: Two Ways to Be Spiritual, and Only One Heals
March 12, 2025 · 7 min read

Two people can hold the same faith and practice it identically — and one grows anxious while the other grows well. Robert Emmons's research suggests the difference is not what you believe, but which way you are facing.
I was raised under a watching God. In my childhood home, God was mostly invoked as a set of eyes that saw everything I did and a hand that punished me when I did wrong. Religion, as it reached me, was a long list of things to avoid — sins to steer clear of, guilt to outrun, punishment to dodge. I carried the residue of that for decades, long after I thought I'd left it behind.
It turns out there is a name for what was wrong with it, and it comes not from theology but from the psychology laboratory.
The psychologist Robert Emmons has spent his career studying what he calls people's ultimate concerns — the highest goals that organize a life. And he has found something with real consequences for anyone seeking peace: spiritual lives come in two directions, and they do not lead to the same place.
An avoidance spirituality is organized around getting away from something bad: avoiding sin, escaping guilt, not being punished, not falling short. An approach spirituality is organized around moving toward something good: growth, love, union, service, the sacred met in ordinary life. On the surface two people can look equally devout — same prayers, same practices. But Emmons's research is clear: avoidance-driven spirituality is associated with more anxiety and depression, while approach-driven spirituality predicts genuine well-being.
The astonishing part is that the difference is not the beliefs. It's the direction. You can hold the very same faith in a way that shrinks you or a way that expands you. The move that matters is the turn from away-from to toward.
That single distinction reorganized my understanding of my own life. The religion of my childhood was pure avoidance, and it made me anxious and small, exactly as the research would predict. The spirituality I slowly grew into in my adult years was an approach — a turning toward union, toward appreciation, toward a reality I could love rather than fear. And that is when well-being arrived. I hadn't changed how much I believed. I had changed which way I was facing.
You can test which one is running your inner life. Listen to the tone of your own spiritual (or simply moral) self-talk. Is it mostly "Don't, or else" — a running audit of your failures and a fear of being found wanting? Or is it "Toward, because" — a pull toward the good you love? The first is avoidance. The second is approach.
And you can begin to turn. Emmons and his colleagues describe a practice called sanctification — coming to see the ordinary parts of your life as sacred and meaningful. The dishes, the drive, the difficult conversation, the work you do for others — when these are experienced as sacred, as expressions of what you most value, they become sources of well-being rather than chores to endure. Notice, too, when you're trying to stop displeasing (yourself, others, God) and gently reframe it: what would it look like to move toward pleasing, toward the good you actually want?
The punishing God of my childhood nearly convinced me that the spiritual life was a matter of fear. It is not. Turn around. The same practices, faced the other way, become the road home.
